Re: Principles of XML design
Elliotte Harold wrote: > > I do wonder if the attribute order issue suggests a possible way out of > the conundrum though. Attribute order in XML is not significant, period. > This was required not by the original first edition XML spec but by the > SGML spec which XML 1.0, first edition, incorporates by reference. > > Does this same SGML spec place any other requirements on SGML and by > extension XML processors? In particular does it mandate anything that an > SGML processor is expected to return to client applications? Do any of > the SGML gurus on the list happen to know that? ISO 8879:1986 didn't specify what data a parser was required to return to the application; that was added later in the Element Structure Information Set (ESIS) attachment. I don't remember if 8879 was ever amended to include the ESIS attachment, but it was pretty much universally adopted. There's a copy here: http://xml.coverpages.org/WG8-n931a.html It's more or less equivalent to the items listed in the XML Information Set, minus the stuff that's new in XML (like namespaces), plus some stuff that was removed (like link rules). The ESIS spec introduced an important idea, the difference between "structure-controlled" and "markup-sensitive" applications: | 1. A structure-controlled SGML application operates | only on the element structure that is described by | SGML markup, never on the markup itself. | | 2. A markup-sensitive SGML application can act on the | actual SGML markup and can act on element structure | information as well. Examples include SGML-sensitive | editors and markup validators. Later, DSSSL and HyTime TC1 introduced the notion of groves and grove plans, along with a modularized definition of the full SGML property set. This spec is much more concrete than the ESIS, and is extensible -- it's good for describing things like the structure of parsed microcontent (e.g., SVG) or augmentation processes (e.g., a WXS PSVI). --Joe English jenglish@f...
PURCHASE STYLUS STUDIO ONLINE TODAY!
Purchasing Stylus Studio from our online shop is Easy, Secure and Value Priced!
Download The World's Best XML IDE!
Accelerate XML development with our award-winning XML IDE - Download a free trial today!
Subscribe in XML format