Re: Future of XSL-FO at W3C??
On Sunday 20 October 2002 9:40 pm, J.Pietschmann wrote: > Ian Tindale wrote: > > ... > > > > The flow notion is quite odd, ... > > Look at the internal document object model of (admittedly a proprietary > > solution, but one that works in the real world) QuarkXpress, which is > > simply a tool that allows a designer to place boxes on a page... > > Umm, I *like* flows, preciesely because I don't want to take > up the mouse and place all these boxes manually. That's what > the FO processor is supposed to do for me. True, there is that. In Xpress one can make a master page set that has an automatic text box (perhaps with columns, perhaps with static items repelling parts of column flow, etc) and when you import the text it simply flows in, generating more pages automatically to fit. Impressive, but most designers turn off the feature that generates more pages automatically. If you've got a certain allocation of space, that's it - that's your territory, and it isn't / shouldn't change. Unbounded flow can mock this line in the sand. Basically, I think I'm saying that the flow notion can be harmful unless you're a] working on a 'free' media, (such as screen, and scroll down and there's more 'screen' - ie, not paper, which costs money per more pages) and b] there's in implicit understanding that the flow feature isn't a saviour (after a decade of browsers that simply can't present balanced columns (sidestepping the argument as to whether side-by-side columns are appropriate on electronic screens of unpredictable size or format)), it can get you into trouble if left to roam free. Don't get me wrong - flow is good - but when it meets paper, and things go wrong, it can cost. Ask any beginner designer who doesn't know how to set section-starts in Xpress and keeps having to hide those 10 or 20 intermediate blank pages they keep printing out each time. -- Ian Tindale
PURCHASE STYLUS STUDIO ONLINE TODAY!
Purchasing Stylus Studio from our online shop is Easy, Secure and Value Priced!
Download The World's Best XML IDE!
Accelerate XML development with our award-winning XML IDE - Download a free trial today!
Subscribe in XML format