Re: Future of XSL-FO at W3C??
Ian Tindale wrote: > Basically, I think I'm saying that the flow notion can be harmful unless > you're a] working on a 'free' media, (such as screen, and scroll down and > there's more 'screen' - ie, not paper, which costs money per more pages) and > b] there's in implicit understanding that the flow feature isn't a saviour ... > Don't get me wrong - flow is good - but when it meets paper, and things go > wrong, it can cost. I'm not sure I understand what you want to say. 1. You can use XSLFO to place boxes: there are absolutely positioned block containers. There are some demos for nice paper forms using this technique. You've still the fo:flow element though, because said block-containers have to be placed in it. 2. TeX is based on a concept which is basically the same as XSLFO flows. A great many paper books have been produced with TeX, I personally was involved for one or two. If things went wrong, this was quickly noticed using an onscreen preview. I never noticed anyone having a major problem with flowing text when it came to produce books or journal articles. 3. I have produced quite a few paper booklets using XML -> (XSLT) -> XSLFO -> (FO formatter) -> PDF -> Printer Quite a few people have been made happy by providing them with a nicely paginated PDF having the same content as the HTML page they look at, so that they can print it for making notices or taking it to read it in the train. Well, perhaps: > If you've got a > certain allocation of space, that's it - that's your territory, and it isn't > / shouldn't change. Sounds like newspaper layout, or marketing brochures. Cool, but hardly the only area in publishing. > Ask any beginner designer who doesn't know how to set > section-starts in Xpress and keeps having to hide those 10 or 20 intermediate > blank pages they keep printing out each time. The FO formatter I use does not produce blank pages until the FO source specifically requires it. Oh well, it happens that unwanted blank pages are produced. This is considered a bug, and usually the style sheet which generates the FO has to be fixed. J.Pietschmann
PURCHASE STYLUS STUDIO ONLINE TODAY!
Purchasing Stylus Studio from our online shop is Easy, Secure and Value Priced!
Download The World's Best XML IDE!
Accelerate XML development with our award-winning XML IDE - Download a free trial today!
Subscribe in XML format