XML in the alleged Real World (was Re: Does XML-Dev matter?)
3/24/2002 3:48:24 AM, AndrewWatt2000@a... wrote: > > Seriously, what was indicated as being overwhelming about XSLT? If the > alleged real world doesn't get XSLT what hope is there for comprehension of > the more complete XML Jigsaw / XML Spaghetti (choose your term according to > taste)? > > > And just for completeness what were the characteristics of the "real world" > which you mention? The slice of the "real world" I visited was in Europe, and the people I referred to were people with long experience in IT who had used XML (and simple XSLT apps) for a year or two, but "hit the wall" trying to implement actual customer requirements for Web applications using XSLT. I'm not talking about a big sample of people, I'm talking about a sense I got from a few conversations: XSLT is good for simple things, hard for hard things, and the tools don't help with the hard stuff. But the "what hope is there for the whole tangled ball of X-spaghetti if experienced software developers have trouble applying one of the best and most widely supported specs" is PRECISELY the point. Tim Bray's presentation makes us think about how other innovative technologies became accepted by the mainstream or not. It seems more and more clear that those tools that help people get their Day Jobs done without making them bet their careers on learning a new, complex way of working are those that tend to succeed. I don't spend enough time in the Real World outside XML geekdom to have strong opinions on where the 80/20 point in XML (broadly defined) really is, but I think that's exactly the question we should be asking ourselves, one another, and our customers. I mentioned this all in response to a question "Does XML-DEV Matter?" -- I say it *does* matter because questions like this have been asked and wrestled with here for years, even if the answers are not yet obvious. Maybe it's value is like that of a sailor's bar in the 15th century - if you don't have a good map to guide you, the gossip -- about who headed where, who came back, and who didn't -- is a WHOLE lot better than nothing.
PURCHASE STYLUS STUDIO ONLINE TODAY!
Purchasing Stylus Studio from our online shop is Easy, Secure and Value Priced!
Download The World's Best XML IDE!
Accelerate XML development with our award-winning XML IDE - Download a free trial today!
Subscribe in XML format