Re: What Does SOAP/WS Do that A REST System Can't?
Michael Champion wrote: > In a resource-oriented architecture, new features are handled by > defining new URIs to manipulate,, new interpretations of HTTP return > codes, new synatax or semantics of the documents transferred, > whatever. How can clients nott need to understand those details in > order to use the features? Or better yet, point me to a concrete > example on the Web. > > Dare mentions than in a service-oriented aggregator, " If later on a a > new service shows up (e.g. getRecentBookmarks() to get RSS feeds from > del.icio.us) then the client has to be upgraded." Sure, but > SOMETHING on the client has to change in a RESTful version as well ... > not the method for retrieving data, which can be GET, but the logic > for doing anything that understands the distinction between a news > story and a bookmark has to come from somewhere. That's the point. You get more flexibility as to where and how you apply processing logic. That's a huge software win that one might not appreciate from a the vantage of a whiteboard. In a getThis, getThat protocol framework, you seem to end up playing infrastructure catchup and trying to keep clients and servers in sync. Basically by hardcoding This and That into the method names you're making questionable assumptions about the range of operations you will need to support. Abstractly speaking it's all processing, concretely speaking having control of how processing occurs and how code is dispatched is critical. Systems with flexible and deferred dispatching modes are almost always cheaper and easier to maintain. For a not completely dissonant comparison, in OO systems where not all possible types can be ranged over at design time (because no-one knows how many more types there will be alter on), plugin and delegation absed architectures are almost always preferrable way to deal with that problem. cheers Bill
PURCHASE STYLUS STUDIO ONLINE TODAY!
Purchasing Stylus Studio from our online shop is Easy, Secure and Value Priced!
Download The World's Best XML IDE!
Accelerate XML development with our award-winning XML IDE - Download a free trial today!
Subscribe in XML format