Re: Relax NG, Thoughts, etc.
Michael Kay wrote: >>There are 5 standard Validation Languages: >> >>1. DTD >>2. XML Schemas >>3. RelaxNG >>4. Schematron >>5. OASIS CAM >> >>But the following technologies have been created to only >>utilize one of them >>(XML Schemas): >> >>a. XSLT >>b. XPath >>c. XQuery >>d. SOAP >>e. WSDL >> >> >> > >Although all of 1-5 might do validation, only one of them does data typing, >and XSLT/XPath/XQuery are using XML Schema as a data typing language, not >primarily as a validation language. > > Daniela already answered to that. >However, integrating output validation into XSLT is, I think, the biggest >"quick win" that schema integration brings, and there's no technical reason >why this part of the story shouldn't work equally well with other schema > > There are actually many reasons why validation should not work equally well with other schema languages. >languages. You won't see anything standardised in this round, but it >wouldn't be surprising to see vendor extensions in this area. In principle >it should be straightforward for an XSLT processor (even a 1.0 processor) to >support result tree validation using any class that implements the JAXP 1.3 >ValidatorHandler interface. > > > Granted, dynamic validation (=at runtime) is always possible, but it is certainly not a big help. Errors are discovered after having gone to production, doesn't sound good to me. But one should not forget to mention that static typing (using the validation language to determine at compile time) is certainly more useful, and simply not possible with some of the mentioned approaches. I am sure you will not try to add exact static typing based on Relax NG for XSLT in the next version of Saxon? There are papers that analyze this for subsets of XSLT, but doing it exactly, for the full language, is - as far as I remember - undecidable. cheers, Burak -- Burak Emir http://lamp.epfl.ch/~buraq
PURCHASE STYLUS STUDIO ONLINE TODAY!
Purchasing Stylus Studio from our online shop is Easy, Secure and Value Priced!
Download The World's Best XML IDE!
Accelerate XML development with our award-winning XML IDE - Download a free trial today!
Subscribe in XML format