Re: Re: Hostility to "binary XML" (was Re: XML 2004
> FWIW, the show-stopper argument in a number of discussions at XML 2004 > that I heard against the idea that "XML text is ubiquitous, don't mess > with it" was from the wireless people: XML is NOT ubiquitous in our > world, because of the excessive bandwidth requirements. Our technical > constraints are fundamental and not going away anytime soon, so don't > expect Moore's Law to make everything alright the way it has made > convenient but inefficient approaches work on the desktop and on the > server. With a statement like that you seriously devalue the signal mismatch problems using XML has solved for a GREAT MANY situations. I suspect that's not your intent. That it may require a degree of syntax beyond that of ultra-sparse textual or binary doesn't address all aspects of "efficiency". That a document can be /read/ by the end-developer is orders of magnitude more efficient than some brittle format mired in obscurity. So please, don't fling complaints about efficiencies when you've only your situation to consider. A great many of us are quite willing to recognize the value gained by using descriptive markup. > In other words, it's time to experiment, to > develop specs that meet the needs of some specific industry, to see if > parsing and compression technology for XML text can be dramatically > improved .... and THEN to come back with data and best practices in > hand to see if W3C Recommendations can be agreed upon. Can't argue with that as an idea. In practice, however, wireless carriers have been notoriously bad at considering anything even slightly beyond their own greed and self-interest. It's certainly a chicken-egg situation and without more effective cooperation from the carriers it's going to stay that way. -Bill Kearney
PURCHASE STYLUS STUDIO ONLINE TODAY!
Purchasing Stylus Studio from our online shop is Easy, Secure and Value Priced!
Download The World's Best XML IDE!
Accelerate XML development with our award-winning XML IDE - Download a free trial today!
Subscribe in XML format