Re: XML 1.1 and Unicode normalization
John Cowan wrote: > > james anderson scripsit: > > > it would be clear how to proceed if xml-11 incorporates charmod and requires > > processors to normalize - thereby entailing normalization-checking. > > > > to specify that the processor must, at option, check normalization, but must > > not transform to normal form, while the referenced specification requires that > > all "producers of strings" ensure (not just check) that they are normalized, > > led this implementer to put the proposals back, to wait for later versions. > > XML parsers are considered consumers, not producers. that is one of the less intuitively obvious things in these specs. > Therefore, > they should normalization-check in accordance with CharMod. For practical > reasons it was decided not to make normalization-checking required. there's this passage in charmod which goes something like "a text processing component [an instance of which i would expect an xml processor to be] that receives suspect text [instances of which i would, in general, expect documents to be] must not perform any normalization-sensistive operations [instances of which i would expect any name construction and comparison operations to be] unless it has first confirmed through inspection that the text is in normalized form, ...." which renders the distinction between consumers and producers academic. unless there some way to interpret the passage so that it does not apply to things like start/end tag matching, attribute defaulting, and validation. what is more, the passage continues with the proscription, that "[a text processing component] must not normalize the suspect text." which left me wondering whether a parser would be conformant if, when it signalled an exception upon determining that it was about to construct a name from a non-nfc string, it at least offered the application a restart which attempted to normalize the namestring and continue. ...
PURCHASE STYLUS STUDIO ONLINE TODAY!
Purchasing Stylus Studio from our online shop is Easy, Secure and Value Priced!
Download The World's Best XML IDE!
Accelerate XML development with our award-winning XML IDE - Download a free trial today!
Subscribe in XML format