Re: Semantic Web and First Order Logic
Bullard, Claude L (Len) wrote, > Can you tell me why decidability was given that level of importance? > This is what I meant by "over-engineered" when I could have said > "over-specified". No idea. Decidable systems are guaranteed to give answers in finite time. That sounds great until you remember that "finite" extends well beyond the expected lifespan of the universe. I think it's just a cool formal property rather than having any real practical import. It's also a hot research topic at the formal end of academic AI, so there are papers to be written and research projects to be done. I guess that's attractive to some. But it's unnecessarily constraining: for all that inferences in an undecidable system aren't guaranteed to terminate, in many practical cases they will. After all, when was the last time you worried about the halting problem wrt a business system? > There is a paper from TimBL on the issue of FOL and the SemWeb at > > http://www.w3.org/DesignIssues/Logic > > which I have trouble following not being well-trained or just not able > to determine his conclusions. Dan Connoly comments on it elsewhere. As far as I can make it out, TimBL and I are more or less in agreement here. I've no idea if that represents his current position. > At first, I thought it the case that the notion was to not require FOL > so that other logic systems could be used as needed, or as in the > spirit of HTML, to make initial fielding easy and get some mind share. > Your arguments make me unsure because requiring decidability would > seemingly make it harder and cut the SemWeb away from uptake of where > the majority of the world's business semantics reside: relational > databases with client or server based business rules and logic in the > form of code libraries. This would appear to limit the role of the > semweb to being merely metadata about web pages, and that isn't that > useful. So that can't be right. Can't it? ;-) Cheers, Miles
PURCHASE STYLUS STUDIO ONLINE TODAY!
Purchasing Stylus Studio from our online shop is Easy, Secure and Value Priced!
Download The World's Best XML IDE!
Accelerate XML development with our award-winning XML IDE - Download a free trial today!
Subscribe in XML format