RE: Just Can't Get No REST
From: Paul Prescod [mailto:paul@p...] Bullard, Claude L (Len) wrote: >> Well, humans. The semantic web has a long evolution >> in front of it to beat the troublemakers and for that >> reason, frictionless business based on loosely coupled >> REST principles (based on URIs and GETs) won't work readily. >Business has friction because business should have a certain amount of >friction (e.g. accountants and auditors). Technology that adds >integration friction to the social friction is just overhead. Maybe. Sometimes it is worth slowing a process down, but that should be built in and not a side effect. Do remember the Thule Greenland incident in 1960. Had the process been running in machine time, North America and most of Europe and Asia would still be cinders. Humans should stay in the loop. >> It may be just as doable to lie to RPC, but it isn't >> as easy. >Why not? Because setting up a web service takes a certain amount of savvy. Almost any idiot can build a web page and plant references to toss google a curve. Sure, that is the idea, but it means we have to vette sources and Google being somewhat uncaring or laissez faire (as it should be) isn't always a trustworthy source. One pays for quality and it may be the case that for some kinds of information, one will pay to ensure it is vetted. Yes that is a stratified web. Yes it is happening and inevitable, IMO. One aspect of the semantic web could be the detail, consistency, and verifiability of such promises. This is where the semantic web and web services have mutual interests: reliable assertions. >IMHO, tricking computers is always easy, whether you use RPC, REST, >asynchronous messaging or whatever. Easy for thee. You are not the average bear. Obscurity is not security and difficulty won't always make things less likely, but likely to make things less likely. What the article showed was the ease with which one could game Google. At one point, it was suggested that what Discovery systems were proposed for (eg, UDDI), Google could do. Google can but the results are worth about what one pays for them. Therefore, caveat emptor. len
PURCHASE STYLUS STUDIO ONLINE TODAY!
Purchasing Stylus Studio from our online shop is Easy, Secure and Value Priced!
Download The World's Best XML IDE!
Accelerate XML development with our award-winning XML IDE - Download a free trial today!
Subscribe in XML format