Cart
|
[XML-DEV Mailing List Archive Home] [By Thread] [By Date] [Recent Entries] [Reply To This Message] Re: RE: Namespaces Best Practice
 [Jonathan Borden] >It seems to me that placing the prefix-URI bindings at the top would ease >this task, but if you would rather perform this somewhere else in a >document, then I see no problem. What ever is more clear for a person to >read. (this -ought- not make any difference to a well designed XML parser so >this guideline exists entirely to allow people, so inclined, to better read >XML documents) Is it just down to human readability? The placement of the prefix-URI bindings used in document branch X effects the contextual dependencies of X. These contextual dependencies have a significant effect on the extent to which fragment X can be treated as a tree in its own right-rather than as a branch of another tree. One of the beauties of tree structures is that the tree/branch distinction can depend on your point of view. Many beautiful algorithms exploit this self-similarity. i.e. algorithms that process a tree by treating the tree as a collection of smaller trees etc. Implicit in such algorithms is that the interpretation of a branch does not require information from beyond the branch. prefix-URI bindings of course get it the way as they they make branch scope vital to the semantics of the branch. If the bindings can occur anywhere in the hierarchy of the tree then the only way to re-introduce the a-branch-is-a--tree-is-a-branch view is to expand all the namespaces. Disagreements about how to do this on this list lead me to believe that this simple sounding task hides numerous wasps nests. This, I think, is very unfortunate. Doesn't it force us to think of XML documents monolithically? Doesn't it make the phrase "XML Fragment" oxymoronic at anything but the triturated brain PSVI level? Does it mean the the cosy world of cut'n'paste style XML processing used in, for example, Pyxie http://pyxie.sourceforge.net/ is lost and gone forever? Ah, the years, the years, Down their carved names, The raindrops plough Sean 
|
PURCHASE STYLUS STUDIO ONLINE TODAY!Purchasing Stylus Studio from our online shop is Easy, Secure and Value Priced! 
Download The World's Best XML IDE!Accelerate XML development with our award-winning XML IDE - Download a free trial today! Subscribe in XML format
|
|||||||||
