Cart
|
[XML-DEV Mailing List Archive Home] [By Thread] [By Date] [Recent Entries] [Reply To This Message] RE: Foreign Names
 Hi Don, Don said: 1. Out of six billion people, how many millions know how to use HTML which uses western alphabets for element types? What were the difficulties in teaching HTML to people whose native language is not based on western alphabet? Didier replies: Some languages like HTML are somewhat related to English. People talking other languages uses this language as is and this is a good thing. However, I encountered many times during my career domain laguages encoded in foreign languages. Both the data content and the elements, comments, attributes and so forth where encoded in German, French, Japanese, Chinese, etc. The creators of these languages created them for internal use of for usage within their country. For instance, in the SGML world, a lot of documents - in Japan - are encoded in Shift-JIS and the element, attributes, etc.. are encoded in Japanese. What we can say though is that some languages like HTML became very popular and some other are used only within the boundaries of a corporation, an institution or a country. I doubt that English speaking countries would adopt a foreign language vocabulary but the probability is higher in Europe where people are accustomed to several languages and where people often speak more than one language. We should not forget that the new born European federation or more particularly their common market, common currency and their 300 million consumers could change our monolithic view of the world. Conclusion: The beauty of actual markup languages is that they allow the creation of new languages in about any language. When you do some international work - and speaking 4 languages I had to do a lot of that :-) - you can notice - as I did for example in Germany (having to look at some procedural language code produced there) - that the variable names are often German names, that comments are also in German. In fact, everything except the reserved keywords of the domain language. You can also notice that if these people wrote their comments in German it is because they are more comfortable to do so than with any other language. That they are using foreign language keywords only because of the constraint of the compiler or the interpreter (because of an obvious lack of sophistication of our primitive tools) not because they choused to do so. I'll repeat the last sentence to be sure that it is understood: They used domain laguages based on foreign language keywords, not because they choused it or because they are more confortable with, simply because the lack of sophistication of our tools forced them to do so. They had to adapt to these tools instead of the contrary. Bottom line. Don said: 2. Are there any keyboards in the world that will not type ASCII? I had to install new software and learned how to type Korean, but all Korean keyboards allows you to type ASCII. Didier replies: OK what about Japanese and Chinese now. When you use a Chinese keyboard, it is not so easy to switch from Chinese to ascii. But this is not the point. The point is that a Chinese element can make more sense for Chinese people than an English markup. It is already a fact that in Japan, we already have SGML documents with markup elements encoded in Japanese. Have you ever looked at a Japanese windows version? The menus are not in ascii as far as I know and there are good reasons for it. Again, these people are using English based procedural or functional languages not by choice but because of a lack of sophistication of the tools not even being able to adapt to these people. I do not want to put more time on this thread since, I think it is obvious that limiting the world to a single culture is a crime against humanity. I also think that there is room for simplified versions of XML that use only ASCII as there is room for more sophisticated tools that can adapt to humans and not the contrary. As there is room for an XML sophisticated enough to allow the creation of domain languages in about any language. Even better, if we are smart enough to create tools that can provide mapping from a language to an other, this is even better. In conclusion, I have nothing against a simplified version of XML that only uses ASCII as long as XML allows us more versatility and the usage of other languages as it is already the case throughout the world. And no (this is for David) to choose their native language to create domain language is not restricted to French speaking people, I encountered documents having elements encoded in Japanese, Chinese, German, Swedish, French and English. And imagine, this is only the limited world a single individual could reach. I am convinced that the reality is even more diverse than that. For sure, after having lived in more than 7 countries and having to learn several language, all this helped me to develop a different view of world :-) Conclusion: There is even no question to ask here, yes you can create a limited tool based on ASCII only. Can this tool be used by 1 billion Chinese individuals? or 300 millions Europeans in, let's say 50 years from now? The world as we know it will change as china and Europe will also change. Will we get a homogeneous English speaking world then? I doubt. Maybe our children are better to learn Chinese ;-) cheers Didier PH Martin ---------------------------------------------- Email: martind@n... Conferences: XML Europe (http://www.gca.org) Book: XML Professional (http://www.wrox.com) column: Style Matters (http://www.xml.com) Products: http://www.netfolder.com *************************************************************************** This is xml-dev, the mailing list for XML developers. To unsubscribe, mailto:majordomo@x...&BODY=unsubscribe%20xml-dev List archives are available at http://xml.org/archives/xml-dev/ *************************************************************************** 
|
PURCHASE STYLUS STUDIO ONLINE TODAY!Purchasing Stylus Studio from our online shop is Easy, Secure and Value Priced! 
Download The World's Best XML IDE!Accelerate XML development with our award-winning XML IDE - Download a free trial today! Subscribe in XML format
|
|||||||||
