[XML-DEV Mailing List Archive Home] [By Thread] [By Date] [Recent Entries] [Reply To This Message] RE: URIs and Names on the Web
> 1) Use HTTP URIs to name whatever (i.e. the range of http is not limited > 2) Use HTTP URIs to name documents, but name arbitrary things as fragments > 3) Use URNs to name whatever > 4) Use new top level schemes to name each new class of resource What's wrong with #3? > 3) URNs aren't widely used, and I can't easily publish my names using URNs What does that mean? It sounds suspiciously like this argument is saying "I can't easily use non-http URIs as http-accessible representation dispensers" URNs are definitely *not* widely used as http endpoints, which is exactly as it should be. If you want to use something as an http endpoint, you name it as an http endpoint. For things that are not intended to be used as http endpoints, URNs are just as widely used as anything else. > or worsen the confusion? It seems to me that the arbitrary '#' is more > confusing, so I'd like to hear a coherent, comprehensive, and easily I agree. > 1) I don't have easy access to a server that do anything with any URNs > that I might create. Do you mean you don't have a server that runs Jenna RDF API? Or do you mean that you don't have access to a server that accepts non-http URIs and treats them as if they *are* http endpoints? If the latter, maybe there is no problem. It seems fundamentally incorrect for a server to take things that are *not* hypermedia representation dispenser endpoints and pretend that they are. The current behavior of clients (which is to assume that only URIs in the http: scheme are used as hypermedia representation dispensers) seems pretty reasonable. > 2) Client software that deals with URNs is not widespread. Right. Client software that is capable of dealing with "hypermedia representation dispensers" *is* widespread. There is already widespread support for identifiers that locate hypermedia servers. The current situation is great if the main thing you want to do is share location of hypermedia representation dispensers.
|
PURCHASE STYLUS STUDIO ONLINE TODAY!Purchasing Stylus Studio from our online shop is Easy, Secure and Value Priced! Download The World's Best XML IDE!Accelerate XML development with our award-winning XML IDE - Download a free trial today! Subscribe in XML format
|