[XML-DEV Mailing List Archive Home] [By Thread] [By Date] [Recent Entries] [Reply To This Message] Re: When to Validate XML?
Some form of validation is necessary at both the sender and receiver's end. In the pre-XML days, the validation is done via 'application logic' on both ends. However, IMHO, XML complicated matters here. For most starters, schemas seem to be a place to keep all their validation logic - however schemas are not expressive enough for this purpose. So, I've often heard complaints that one has to do to lot more validation besides what the schemas offer. So, there is some logic in the applications, and some more in the schemas. I don't see anything wrong in this - each of these validations may in fact be serving different purposes. > Another consideration is the cost of rejecting a "semantically" valid > document that happens to have some syntax out of place. My favorite > (hypothetical) example is a $1000000 purchase order with a private attribute > in it somewhere; would you really reject it? If "reject" means turn it over > to a human, sure ...But if you're using human or programmed business logic > look the documents over anyway, why bother validating the XML in the first > place? Good example. Such a document may be "invalid" as per a schema or DTD. But it is perfectly valid from the business sense. So, how to deal with such documents when the sender and receiver wanted (for whatever reasons) schema-based validation (in addition to application level validation)? The all-or-none style parsers die on such documents. Do we need a different kind of parsers which can process "invalid" documents, and tell us at the end what the violations are? > Another impression I've received over the years is that validation (via > DTDs, Schemas, or whatever) tends to be more of an "audit time" activity > than a real-time activity. The DTD or schema represents a "contract" between Precisely. However, the sender/receiver should be able to apply some discretion. In the above $1000000 purchase order example, the receiver may want to process it just because there are big bucks with it - the receiver can do so as long as there is "enough" information to process the purchase-order. Subbu
|
PURCHASE STYLUS STUDIO ONLINE TODAY!Purchasing Stylus Studio from our online shop is Easy, Secure and Value Priced! Download The World's Best XML IDE!Accelerate XML development with our award-winning XML IDE - Download a free trial today! Subscribe in XML format
|